The artistic nature in the 14th and 15th books of Galen’s On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30827/floril.v33i.26532Keywords:
nature; artisan; foetal development; reproductive system.Abstract
In the 14th and 15th books of the galenic work On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body, dedicated to male and female reproductive organs and foetal development, the author presents nature (φύσις), the agent of the human body’s formation, as artistic and admirable, because it used an art (τέχνη) to make immortality possible, which consists in replacing one living being by another in an admirable way. Such an art is also related to a divine purpose, once nature’s action, possessing an intrinsic ability, is that of a demiurge. So, if, on the one hand, we have an artistic and practical nature, whose activity is proved by dissection and visible in the position and function of male and female reproductive organs, on the other, we have an abstract concept of the same nature, working to perpetuate humankind, but whose deepest and more abstract problems are not to be discovered nor solved in medical works such as On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body.
In this paper I will analyse how the concepts of φύσις and τέχνη relate to each other, by developing and deepening the role of nature as an artisan regarding the formation and function of the reproductive system and foetal development and its limits as such, pointing also the different subtleties of the concept.
Downloads
References
Primary Sources
AESCHYLUS (2009), Prometheus vinctus. Edition and English version by Alan H. Sommerstein. Loeb Classical Library 145. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
ARISTOTLE (1957), De anima. Greek text and English version by W. S. Hett. Loeb Classical Library 288. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
ARISTOTLE (1942), De generatione animalium. Greek text and English version by A. L. Peck. Loeb Classical Library 366. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
ARISTOTLE (1937), De incessu animalium. Greek text and English version by A. L. Peck & E. S. Forster. Loeb Classical Libray 323. Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
ARISTOTLE (1937), De partibus animalium. Greek text and English version by A. L. Peck & E. S. Forster. Loeb Classical Libray 323. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
CICERO (1917), De natura deorum. Edition by O. Plasberg. Leipzig, Teubner. http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3atext%3a2007.01.0037 (accessed: 22/10/2022). English version by P.G. Walsh (1997). New York, Oxford University Press.
GALEN (1821), De anatomicis administrationibus. Edition by C.G. Kühn. Leipzig, Knobloch (repr. 2011: Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). English version by Charles Singer (1956). London, Oxford University Press.
GALEN (1822), De foetuum formation. Edition by C.G. Kühn. Leipzig, Knobloch (repr. 2011: Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). English version by P.N. Singer (1997). New York, Oxford University Press.
GALEN (1967), De naturalibus facultatibus. Edition by J. Marquardt, I. Müller & G. Helmreich. Leipzig, Teubner (repr. 1967: Amsterdam, Hakkert). English version by Arthur John Brock (1916). London, William Heinemann.
GALEN (1907), De usu partium. Edition by G. Helmreich. Leipzig, Teubner (repr. 1968: Amsterdam, Hakkert) and by C.G. Kühn (1821: Leipzig, Knobloch; repr. 2011: Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). English version by Margaret Tallmadge May (1968). Ithaca, N.Y, Cornell University Press. Spanish version by Mercedes López Salvá (2010). Madrid, Editoral Gredos.
HOMER (1962), Odyssea. Edition by P. von der Mühll. Basel, Helbing & Lichtenhahn.
http://stephanus.tlg.uci.edu/Iris/Cite?0012:002:0 (accessed: 21/10/2022). English version by Anthony Verity (2016). New York, Oxford University Press.
ISOCRATES (1928), Ad Nicoclem. Greek text and English version by George Norlin. Loeb Classical Library 209. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (1927), Charmides. Greek text and English version by W.R.M. Lamb. Loeb Classical Library 201. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (2017), Euthyphro. Edition and English version by Christopher Emlyn-Jones and William Preddy. Loeb Classical Library 36. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (1926), Hippias minor. Greek text and English version by Harold North Fowler. Loeb Classical Library 167. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (1926), Leges. Greek text and English version by R. G. Bury. Loeb Classical Library 192. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (1921), Sophista. Greek text and English version by Harold North Fowler. Loeb Classical Library 123. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (2013), Respublica. Greek text and English version by Christopher Emlyn-Jones, William Preddy. Loeb Classical Library 276. Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
PLATO (1929), Timaeus. Greek text and English version by R. G. Bury. Loeb Classical Library 234, Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press.
SVF=Stoicorum Veterum Fragmenta (2002). Edition by Hans von Arnim. Italian version by Roberto Radice. Milano, Bompiani.
Secondary sources
BAWDEN, H. (1910), «Art and Nature», The Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods. 7.19: 521-526.
CHAINTRAINE, P. (ed.) (1999), Dictionnaire etymologique de la langue grecque : Histoire des mots. Paris, Klincksieck.
CHIARADONNA, R. (2014), «Galen on what is persuasive (“pithanon”) and what approximates to truth», Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 114: 61-88.
CLOSE, A. (1971), «Philosophical Theories of Art and Nature in Classical Antiquity», Journal of the History of Ideas 32.2: 163-184.
DEVINANT, J. (2020), Les troubles psychiques selon Galien. Étude d’un système de pensée. Paris, Les Belles Lettres.
FLEMMING, R. (2000), «Galen woman» in Medicine and the making of roman women: gender, nature and authority from Celsus to Galen. Oxford, Oxford University Press: 288-374.
GONZALEZ, F. (2018), «The Philosophical Use of Mimesis» in Heather L. Reid & Jeremy C. DeLong (eds.), The Many Faces of Mimesis. Parnassos Press: 23-36.
GOTTLIEB, P. & SOBER, E. (2017), «Aristotle on “Nature Does Nothing in Vain» Hopos: The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science 7.2: 246-271.
HOLMES, B. (2017), «Pure life: the limits of the vegetal analogy in the hippocratics and Galen», in John Z. Wee (ed.), Analogy and Metaphor in Ancient Mesopotamian, Egyptian and Greco-Roman Medicine. Leiden, Brill: 358-387.
JAEGER, W. (1959), «The Greek Ideas of Immortality: The Ingersoll Lecture for 1958», The Harvard Theological Review 52.3: 135-147.
JOUANNA, J. (2012), «Galen’s concept of nature» in Greek Medicine from Hippocrates to Galen. Leiden, Brill: 287-312.
KOVAČIČ, F. (2001), Der Begriff der Physis bei Galen vor dem Hintergrund seiner Vorganger. Stuttgart, Franz Steiner.
KOVAČIČ, F. (2003), «Die Natur als Künstler und Baumeister bei Galen» Traditio 58: 1-57.
NUTTON, V. (2021), «Galen and the sophists» Annali dell'Università degli Studi di Napoli “L'Orientale” 43.1: 114-127.
PENDER, S. (2005), «Between Medicine and Rhetoric», Early Science and Medicine 10.1: 35-64.
PETIT, C. (2018), Galien de Pérgame ou la rhétorique de la Providence. Leiden, Brill.
POWERS, N. (2013), «Plato’s Demiurge as precursor to the stoic providential God», The Classical Quarterly 63.2: 713-722.
SCHAERER, R. (1930), Επιστήμῃ et Τεχνή. Etude sur les notions de connaissance et d’art d’Homère à Platon, Mâcon, Protat frères.
TRENCH, F. (1933), «Mimesis in Aristotle’s Poetics», Hermathena 23.48: 1-24.
VON STADEN, H. (1995), «Anatomy as rhetoric: Galen on dissection and persuasion», Journal of the History of Medicine and allied sciences 50.1: 47-66.
VON STADEN, H. (1997), «Galen and the “second sophistic”», Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 68: 33-54.
WOODRUFF, P. (2015), «Mimesis» in Pierre Destrée & Penelope Murray (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Aesthetics. Oxford, Wiley-Blackwell: 327-340.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
